Condor&Jessica小窩

六月一日丟了一篇文章到Journal of Asian Earth Science

昨天正式回覆"The reviewers have commented on your above paper. They indicate that it could be acceptable after significant revision."

也就是說改完就可以被接受、刊登了

但不懂的是兩位reviewer的意見差了十萬八千里

Reviewer #1: This manuscript present new observation on the Moho depth distribution beneath Taiwan based on the travel time inversion of PmP phases. The estimation method seems reasonable and the result is important for the future modeling of the structure and tectonics of Taiwan. I recommend the paper be published after minor revision. I have comments/suggestions as follows.

這一位極為肯定我的成果，認為對後續的研究是非常重要的

Reviewer #2: This is a roughly organized manuscript in figures information, data analysis, reference citations and result interpretations.

但這一位認為我文章非常粗糙(幾乎整組壞掉掉)

我都懷疑是否是同一篇文章了@@"

但值得高興的是文章沒有被退稿啦*^^*